When we built our home 15 years ago, we installed hand scraped hickory engineered hardwood throughout the main floor. I loved it then and I still do. It has warmth, character and just enough texture to hide everyday life.
But after 15 years of dogs, kids, furniture moving and general ranch traffic, there are now plenty of spots where the finish has worn completely off. And those light, bare wood areas? They catch the eye immediately.
We had a quote to refinish the roughly 1,000 square feet and it came in around $8,000. That also means moving everything out — in the middle of a Canadian winter. Not exactly ideal.
So instead of rushing into a full refinish or replacement, I’ve been using a simple temporary solution to make the wear far less noticeable.
My Temporary Fix: Wood Stain Markers
For now, I use Varathane wood stain touch-up markers to tone down the bare spots.
Here’s what I do:
Clean the area first so there’s no dust or residue.
Choose a tone that blends, not one that matches perfectly. Hickory has variation, so slightly lighter is usually better than too dark. I used 8 on the floor and 11 (black) on the grooves. You can blend colors as well.
Lightly feather the stain into the worn area.
Wipe excess immediately with a blue shop towel so it doesn’t sit in the surrounding finish.
Step back and let it dry before deciding if it needs another pass.
The goal is not perfection — it’s camouflage. Once the raw wood is toned down, your eye stops going straight to it.
Important to Know
This does not replace the protective finish. It’s purely cosmetic. The exposed areas are still technically unsealed, but visually they blend back into the floor and don’t shout at you every time you walk by.
For us, this buys time.
It allows us to:
Live with the floor as-is through winter.
Avoid emptying the entire main floor.
Decide later whether refinishing or replacing makes more sense.
Why I’m Not Spot Poly-Coating
I’ve deliberately avoided trying to patch small areas with polyurethane. Spot clear-coating often leaves shiny patches that are more noticeable than the original wear. With hand scraped texture especially, blending sheen is tricky.
Stain pens fade into the background. Glossy patches do not.
Reality Check
Fifteen years of life on hardwood floors will show. And honestly, hand scraped hickory carries wear better than smooth floors. There’s a difference between damage and lived-in character.
Until we commit to the big decision, this simple touch-up method keeps things looking cared for without the chaos of a full renovation.
Sometimes buying time is the smartest project of all.
Before. And. After
Applying the stain pen video
And wiping back.
The Amazon affiliate links are for your convenience to see the products I used as well. Ordering via the links may get me a small commission but does not affect your pricing. Thank you if you do choose to order them.
FEATURED ON
Shared up at these great link up parties
.jpg)
A simple solution to give more time to make long term plan! Nicely done.
ReplyDeleteIndeed, such a hard decision to make for such a large area
DeleteWow. It looks great. Thank you for sharing this at the Will Blog for Comments #79 linkup. Wishing you a wonderful week to come & looking forward to seeing more of your posts next week at #80.
ReplyDeleteThank you Jennifer for hosting :) and your kind words
Delete